Pull down to go back
Post Rebuttal ICML Average Scores? [D]

Post Rebuttal ICML Average Scores? [D]

ICML 反駁後的平均分數?[D]

A researcher shares frustration about their paper's average score of 3.5 after the rebuttal phase at ICML. One reviewer gave a score of 2 by raising a new concern that wasn't in their initial review—and they apparently borrowed this point from another reviewer who had already dismissed it as not being a real issue. To add insult to injury, Paper Co-Pilot suggests that even a 4.2 only puts you in the top 40% of submissions, making the whole scoring situation feel even more discouraging.

Keywords

paper reviewrebuttalscoringpeer review processacademic conference