Pull down to go back
Will I make it into ICML 2026? My paper just got weak rejects but reviewers hinted they'd raise scores

Will I make it into ICML 2026? My paper just got weak rejects but reviewers hinted they'd raise scores

我的論文能進 ICML 2026 嗎?弱拒審查員暗示加改就會提分

A researcher transitioning from theoretical physics to machine learning shares their ICML 2026 submission journey. After the review period, their paper improved from 4333 to 4433 scores. Two weak reject reviewers indicated they'd likely raise their scores if specific changes were made: one wants a parameter sweep and a small section added (which the author already did), and the other needs their questions properly addressed. The paper focuses on deep learning theory. The author estimates a realistic chance of reaching 4443, with a 30-40% shot at the coveted 4444 (accept). They're cautiously optimistic but clearly anxious about whether these revisions will be enough to push them over the line for acceptance.

Keywords

conference submissionpeer reviewdeep learning theorycareer transitionacceptance chances